What is Art? What is Beauty?

5

We asked Robert Hopkins, President of the European Society for Aesthetics, for his thoughts on these and other questions – Read on for his answers!

Is it possible to define what ‘Art’ is?

I think we’d have to concede that a satisfactory definition has yet to be found. The traditional attempts to define art – as representation, or as the expression of emotion or as whatever is made to repay aesthetic attention – all seem to fail to fit some or other important artwork, or even whole genres or artforms. And more recent attempts to capture art’s essence in sociological terms (more or less, the idea that art is whatever the relevant authorities accept as art) arguably don’t really tell us very much. Some have taken all this to show that art cannot be defined: it is by its very nature too protean, too exploratory and fluid, ever to be captured in a formula. However, it’s not clear that art is harder to define than other concepts. (Try truth, or knowledge, or doing what one ought.) All our most interesting and important ideas resist definition.

Is Beauty only in the eye of the beholder?

Well, what’s the alternative? If the only other option is that beauty is ‘in’ the thing we find beautiful then – assuming we can make sense of this talk of properties being in places at all – I’ll go for the beholder’s eye. But consider colours. Are they ‘in’ objects or ‘in’ the eye of those who see them? That looks like a false choice. Colours may not be fundamental features of the world, the way that shapes or mass are. But nor are they mere fantasms. We can make mistakes about the colour of things (think of colour-blind people, or seeing something in an unsuitable light), and that’s enough for our judgements of colour to have some kind of objectivity. And, although there are complications here, I think things are much the same with beauty. It may not be part of the fundamental furniture of the universe, but nor is it simply something individuals impose on the world.

What makes Photographs special?

Photographs are pictures, and so are special in the way that all pictures are. But photographs are pictures of a special kind. What is special about them, versus other pictures? I’m sympathetic to the thought, which I’ve heard various photographers endorse, that photos are ‘traces’, while other pictures are ‘signs’. What does that mean, though? I think that what distinguishes photographs is that the way they show the world to be depends on how it was, without depending on how the photographer took it to be. That’s not true for other pictures: even when they are accurate, they are so only because the artist sought to show how things are, and herself saw the world accurately. Of course, there are complexities here, to do with the very considerable control the photographer does have over the image. Still, I think those don’t, in the end, alter the underlying facts.

Why do we care about Art?

A good question! One striking feature of most accounts of what art is, is that they completely fail to explain why we’d value it. That’s certainly true of most of the theories I mentioned above – though an honourable exception here is the view that art is expressive, at least as that view was developed by the 20th century English philosopher R.G.Collingwood. Perhaps there is simply nothing, at the utterly general level, to be said about art’s value. Perhaps, in other words, we should start instead by asking why we care about this painting, or that piece of music; or perhaps by asking what there is to care about in (say) painting in general that is not available in music, and vice versa. The deity might be in the detail, if you’ll allow me the pun.

Why do people care that an artwork is an original rather than a forgery?

It’s not really a philosopher’s job to say why in fact people care. However, it is my job to explore why they should care – to find the differences between originals and forgeries that might make it reasonable to prefer the former. The question only really gets interesting if we imagine that the forgery is perfect, i.e. so good that no matter how long one looks, or how expert one’s eye, one will not be able to tell it from the original. Even so, the original will have properties the forgery lacks. The original might, for example, be ground-breaking as art; the forgery can at most be ground-breaking as a copy. In a way, it’s obvious that there can be this sort of difference between the two. So, since I think we all worry that there might really be an issue about whether it’s rational to prefer the original, the question becomes why we might think that these differences somehow don’t count. The answer can only lie in the thought that what is valuable in an artwork must show up in our experience of it. Can the ground-breaking nature of the original do this, even though the indistinguishable forgery lacks that feature? Perhaps surprisingly, I think it can – though I’d need more space than we’ve got here to explain quite how.

Robert Hopkins is the President of the European Society for Aesthetics and Head of Philosophy at The University of Sheffield in the UK.

Want to bring real life beauty back? Head to the Microsite, take part in our Shoot Your Prophecy Competition and download the Future is Analogue posters!

written by tomas_bates on 2011-03-18 #future #philosophy #art #lifestyle #beauty #analogue

5 Comments

  1. neja
    neja ·

    herr Willie!!!!

  2. ali55
    ali55 ·

    very interesting :)

  3. cyan-shine
    cyan-shine ·

    Wow, some great images with this article, but where are the photographer credits??????????

  4. juxtimon
    juxtimon ·

    interesting article :)

  5. coryk0303
    coryk0303 ·

    great way to start the morning !

More Interesting Articles

  • Emily Soto: In the Studio with the Daguerreotype Achromat Art Lens

    written by Lomography on 2016-05-04 #news #gear #people
    Emily Soto: In the Studio with the Daguerreotype Achromat Art Lens

    Fashion photographer Emily Soto is known for her dreamy, elegant portraiture so we thought she'd be a perfect candidate to test the Daguerreotype Achromat 2.9/64 Art Lens. She answers a few questions on the experience in this interview.

    3
  • The Art of Picture Taking: An Interview with Filmmaker Catherine Dauphin

    written by Azin Teimoori on 2016-02-16 #videos #people
    The Art of Picture Taking: An Interview with Filmmaker Catherine Dauphin

    At the time of its inception, photography was considered less a fine art and more a scientific method of reproduction. But anyone who has dabbled in the craft will argue otherwise; that there consists a very specific artistry in the photographic medium. We spoke with Luxembourg-based filmmaker Catherine Dauphin about her thoughts on this wonderful art form. Join us as she answers some of our questions about film, photography, and her short film titled "The Art of Picture Taking."

  • Inspiring and Daring Women in Contemporary Photography (Part I)

    written by lomographymagazine on 2016-03-08 #people
     Inspiring and Daring Women in Contemporary Photography (Part I)

    We love a striking photo as much as the next person, but a unique point of view makes us head straight to a feature. Who should the world know more about? Who has rocked our perception of beauty, sexuality and creativity? These questions populate our notepads, and our list of photographers is quite long. For International Women's Day 2016, we whittle the directory down to our current favorites, photographers who resist labels (even the ones we give them) and dare the world to see what they see.

  • Shop News

    LomoLab Europe has moved!

    LomoLab Europe has moved!

    The LomoLab EU has moved and is now open for business! Analogue lovers from Austria, Germany, Spain, Netherlands, Belgium, Luxenbourg, and the rest of Europe can send their films to: Lomographische AG LomoLAB Kaiserstrasse 34/12 1070 WIen Austria However, if you're based in Germany - and you don't mind a longer waiting time, you can still send your rolls for processing to: Lifesmyle Store Berlin - LomoLAB Friedrichstraße 133 10117 Berlin Germany

  • How the Very First Commercial Instant Camera Came to Be

    written by lomographymagazine on 2015-11-19
    How the Very First Commercial Instant Camera Came to Be

    Children, ever curious and with an innate sense of wonder, ask a lot of questions. Often they're easy enough to answer, but sometimes there are those that leave the adults stumped and mulling over them. The history of the instant camera as we know it began with one such question.

  • Serendipity Exhibition by Toby Mason

    written by lomographysoholondon on 2015-09-10 #news
    Serendipity Exhibition by Toby Mason

    Toby Mason (aka fotobes) is a Brighton-based photographer who embraces the aesthetics of film photography. He mostly shoots with the LC-A+ using a range of slide films, cross processing them to create rich, highly saturated colours. His work has been featured on the BBC website and Hungry Eye Magazine. Join us for the opening night on Thursday, September 17 from 6 p.m.

    2
  • Petzval 58 Amigo: Benjamin Kracke

    written by Azin Teimoori on 2016-02-10 #news #people
    Petzval 58 Amigo: Benjamin Kracke

    Germany-based Benjamin Kracke began his photography journey by searching for something unique. Naturally, the New Petzval 58 Bokeh Control Art Lens proved to be full of character for this LomoAmigo! Read on to find out more about his experience with this beautiful art lens.

  • Shop News

    New Item: iBlazr 2

    New Item: iBlazr 2

    Light up all your shots with this light-weight, versatile and wireless LED flash! Works best with any iOS and android platforms.

  • LomoAmigo Wangs Lok Collects Memories with the Petzval 85 Art Lens

    written by Phyllis Chan on 2016-03-05 #people
    LomoAmigo Wangs Lok Collects Memories with the Petzval 85 Art Lens

    Hong Kong-based photographer Wangs Lok loves the outdoors. For his new set, he used Petzval 85 Art Lens with his Canon 6D to bring a piece of nature back into the city and enact his trailing thoughts.

  • Neil Krug: Pulp, Rock, Color

    written by lomographymagazine on 2015-10-27 #videos #people
    Neil Krug: Pulp, Rock, Color

    In 2009, Neil Krug uploaded a commercial for Pulp Art Book on Youtube. In the comments section someone asked, “Does anyone know what kind of camera he uses or how he gets his pictures to look the way they do?” Krug was on to something. He did something wildly intriguing, one that looked to have a secret formula.

  • Adam Goldberg: Daguerreotype Achromat Art Lens First Impressions

    written by Katherine Phipps on 2016-07-18 #gear #people #tutorials
    Adam Goldberg: Daguerreotype Achromat Art Lens First Impressions

    LomoAmigo Adam Goldberg took the Daguerreotype Achromat Art Lens around NYC to test what he now calls "the stunningly unique bokeh of the lens." Read more about his creation of these surreal double exposures and rave review of the lens here.

  • Shop News

    The New Daguerreotype Achromat 2.9/64 Art Lens now available for pre-order in Shop!

    The New Daguerreotype Achromat 2.9/64 Art Lens now available for pre-order in Shop!

    We're grateful for the overwhelming support from all our KickStarter backers. For those who were late to the party, we're happy to let you know that the Daguerreotype Achromat 2.9/64 Art Lens is now available for pre-order in the shop! Estimated delivery date slated for January 2017!

  • Sohvi Viik – What Is Real Is Imagined

    written by jennifer_pos on 2016-03-08 #news #people
    Sohvi Viik – What Is Real Is Imagined

    Ever since photography has been invented in the early 19th century, people had themselves being photographed. However, in times of smartphone cameras, selfies and social media, recording our daily life in pictures has become a Leitmotiv, a metaphor for a restless society. In her latest solo exhibition, Estonian fine art photographer Sohvi Viik questions the necessity of modern photography.

    1
  • Capturing the Festival Spirit with Trev Eales

    written by hannah_brown on 2015-10-01 #people
    Capturing the Festival Spirit with Trev Eales

    Trev Eales is a UK based music photographer who has shot for various festivals and other events. On this occasion, he turned his attention away from the stage and photographed the audience. With the Petzval 85 Lens, he managed to capture the essence of a very British summer. Expect fancy outfits, hoola hooping, dancing and lots of beautiful, swirly bokeh from this series of festive portraits.

  • Expert Advice: Brian Sweeney's First Impressions of the New Jupiter 3+

    written by azinteimoori on 2016-02-13 #people
    Expert Advice: Brian Sweeney's First Impressions of the New Jupiter 3+

    Where do you go for the most extensive advice on the New Jupiter 3+? To the Jupiter master of course! Engineer and rangefinder enthusiast Brian Sweeney is well known as an expert on the Jupiter 3 and vintage Zeiss Sonnars, and we had the chance to speak with him about his experience with our newest art lens.

    10