The mystery on why people didn’t smile in old portraits – revealed!

2013-09-24 1

Apparently, it’s more of a case of etiquette than having bad teeth.

We’ve already learned that centuries ago, only the privileged and the rich have their portraits painted or shot. We’ve also been able to see portraits from these ages, and have thus observed that people usually don’t smile at all!

‘Miss Eleanor Brooks’ (1890) by John Singer Sargent and a ‘Portrait of Maj. Gen. Gordon Granger of the Federal Army’ (taken between 1860 and 1865). Photos via the John Singer Sargent Virtual Gallery and the Library of Congress

Writer and artist Nicholas Jeeves, in an extensive article titled, The Serious and the Smirk: The Smile in Portraiture revealed that such people used to take on either of these two facial expressions when having their portraits done: a serious one, or a smirk.

Mona Lisa’s ‘enigmatic smile’ – or rather, smirk – has captured the attention of many and sparked numerous discussions over the ages. Photo via Wikipedia

According to him, smirking is a “subtle and complex facial expression [that] may convey almost anything.” On the other hand, people do a serious pose because of – surprise, surprise – eventual discomfort brought by holding a pose for so long. Obviously, it would be extremely uncomfortable and even painful for the subject to hold a smiley pose for hours, or even repeatedly for days until the portrait is finished, so they opt not to.

Also, believe it or not, there had been a time when smiling broadly in general– something so common and pleasant these days – was said to be done only by “the poor, the lewd, the drunk, the innocent, and the entertainment.”

As French priest and reformer St. Jean-Baptiste De La Salle wrote in “The Rules of Christian Decorum and Civility of 1703,”

There are some people who raise their upper lip so high… that their teeth are almost entirely visible. This is entirely contradictory to decorum, which forbids you to allow your teeth to be uncovered, since nature gave us lips to conceal them.

Can you believe that!

Jeeves also debunked the notion that people those days had really bad teeth so they didn’t smile. “…bad teeth were so common that this was not seen as necessarily taking away from someone’s attractiveness,” he wrote.

He went on to discuss how portraits were “never so much a record of a person, but a formalised ideal. He then quoted American author Mark Twain,

A photograph is a most important document, and there is nothing more damning to go down to posterity than a silly, foolish smile caught and fixed forever.

It’s good to learn about such rigid practices and viewpoints for when taking a portrait during the olden days, but thank God we didn’t live during those times!

All information in this article were sourced from The Public Domain Review.

Related article:

Delicate 19th Century Portraits by Julia Margaret Cameron

written by chooolss on 2013-09-24 #paintings #lifestyle #portraits #smirk #analogue-lifestyle #smiling #nicholas-jeeves #jean-baptiste-de-la-salle #the-rules-of-christian-decorum-and-civility-of-1703 #mark-twain

More Interesting Articles

  • Self to the World: The Photography of Leanne Surfleet

    written by lomographymagazine on 2015-11-17 #people
    Self to the World: The Photography of Leanne Surfleet

    A self-portrait may take root in confidence, extreme shyness or alternate bouts of each. Leanne Surfleet goes through this kind of fluctuation when the camera is all eyes. The attraction—as far as we’re concerned—is the mix of uncertainty and a kind of quiet poise. And here and there, a flash of skin that is more a mystery than full-on revelation. Even Surfleet’s portraits of other people have the same hushed invite, as if to say questions are encouraged. There we took our cue.

    2015-11-17
  • Why People in Early Photograph Did Not Smile And Say Cheese

    written by lomographymagazine on 2016-03-07 #videos
    Why People in Early Photograph Did Not Smile And Say Cheese

    A long time ago, when it was impossible to have hundreds of selfies, people did not smile in their portraits.

    2016-03-07
  • Photo of the Day by keith4

    written by Eunice Abique on 2015-09-26 #news
    Photo of the Day by keith4

    Old castles and ruins carry a certain air of mystery that draws the curious lomographer in.

    2015-09-26 2
  • Shop News

    The Lomography Bazaar

    The Lomography Bazaar

    We constantly search far and wide, meticulously seek out, hunt down, and hand-pick some of the most experimental and alternative gear out there - and we've now gathered them all in one easy to browse shop category, ready for the picking! In the Lomo-Bazaar, you canalso be part of our process of collecting fresh new products, rare treasures, and crowd-funded creations to sell on the shop - after all, they’re all for you! Get in touch with us to share your suggestions for amazing gear - go on, we’re all ears!

  • The Photographic Studio: 19th vs. 21st Century

    written by Lomography on 2016-04-23 #gear
    The Photographic Studio: 19th vs. 21st Century

    Photographic studios have existed since the beginning of commercial photography, which was marked by the public announcement of the Daguerreotype process. But imagine this: People had to stay absolutely still for more than 15 minutes just to have their portrait taken!

    2016-04-23
  • Iconic Portrait Lenses Part 2

    written by cheeo on 2016-08-15 #gear
    Iconic Portrait Lenses Part 2

    The second part of this list brings you even more drool-worthy portrait lenses that can give any photographer a serious case of GAS.

    3
  • Behind the Picture: Korea. Posts Along Road Which Were Carved to Prevent Devils From Passing (c. 1920-1927)

    written by lomographymagazine on 2015-10-19
    Behind the Picture: Korea. Posts Along Road Which Were Carved to Prevent Devils From Passing (c. 1920-1927)

    A common sight along roads in old Korea were towering wooden posts with human faces carved on them, the purpose behind their creation more superstitious than aesthetic.

    2015-10-19
  • Shop News

    Great discounts on Instax Mini films when you them with the Lomo'Instant Milano

    Great discounts on Instax Mini films when you them with the Lomo'Instant Milano

    Purchase the newest, coolest, pinkest Lomo'Instant yet, the Lomo'Instant Milano and get up to 20% off the price of film when you buy it with 10 packs of Instax Mini Films!

  • Ferry Verheij: A Story Teller

    written by Ivana Džamić on 2016-07-28 #people
    Ferry Verheij: A Story Teller

    It can be said that photography is more than just a click on the camera, it makes the moments, people and emotions live forever. This was confirmed to us by an exceptional Dutch photographer Ferry Verheij, whose photographs represent stories of all those people and places he had a chance to know.

    2016-07-28 1
  • Select Holiday Shipping Deals for Last Minute Shoppers!

    written by Lomography on 2015-12-17 #news #gear
    Select Holiday Shipping Deals for Last Minute Shoppers!

    Have you been searching for the perfect gift for your loved ones and have yet to find it? Or maybe all of your shopping is done and it's time to treat yourself? Whatever the case may be, you're in luck — we've got awesome holiday shipping deals available around the globe! Depending on what country you order from, any order over €150/£150/$200 may qualify for free express shipping before the cut off dates. Scroll down to see more details!

    2015-12-17
  • Petzval Lenses: The Craft of Portraiture

    written by lomographymagazine on 2016-02-16 #gear
    Petzval Lenses: The Craft of Portraiture

    The Petzval 85 and 58 Lenses remain favorites among Lomographers because of the quality bokeh, perfect for making dreamy portraits, à la classic paintings. But portraiture is more than just showing off a pretty face in a classic, vertical orientation: It's a marriage of elements. Think of it in terms of attitude and personality.

    2016-02-16
  • Shop News

    The New Daguerreotype Achromat 2.9/64 Art Lens now available for pre-order in Shop!

    The New Daguerreotype Achromat 2.9/64 Art Lens now available for pre-order in Shop!

    We're grateful for the overwhelming support from all our KickStarter backers. For those who were late to the party, we're happy to let you know that the Daguerreotype Achromat 2.9/64 Art Lens is now available for pre-order in the shop! Estimated delivery date slated for January 2017!

  • A Secret of the Cosmos: Launching the Newest Lomography Product

    written by Lomography on 2016-01-19 #news #gear
    A Secret of the Cosmos: Launching the Newest Lomography Product

    Shh! We've got a secret matter at hand, and it's coming at you at the speed of light! We're being as mysterious as the Cosmos about our new out-of-this world product, constantly orbiting around our big reveal. But the eclipse will pass and soon the stars will align. Until then, there must be some questions floating around in the universe, right? Well, there's no need to look to the stars to find your answer! Stay on Lomography's wavelength as we kick into hyperdrive. Let your imagination skyrocket and see if you can decipher our otherworldly clues!

    2016-01-19 19
  • The Modest Beauty of Flea Market Photographs

    written by Teresa Sutter on 2016-04-05 #people
    The Modest Beauty of Flea Market Photographs

    A collector of old, anonymous photographs, Thierry Struvay is always on the hunt for those special moments of the past: from spruce family portraits to sexy patent-leather shoes and naked handstands, it's all there.

    2016-04-05
  • Photo of the Day by oldhan

    written by lomography on 2016-02-07 #news
    Photo of the Day by oldhan

    In the eyes of an observant lomographer, a large body of water is more than just a pretty view. It's a useful tool for creating mind-boggling photographs.

    2016-02-07 2