How to Fix Sloppy Redscale Scans from a Minilab with GIMP

2012-08-01 19

We all shoot our films, some of us also process and scan it, but I prefer the convenience of the commercial labs for the purpose. Guess my surprise when I got totally different scans from the same roll!
This GIMP tutorial covers the basic technique that I used to rectify the problem on one of my first home-made Redscale rolls. Although a digital computer and a software program is used, I do not consider that a manipulation, but rather “fixing” an error that has been made by another computer program elsewhere. We are going to analyze the histogram and based on some basic knowledge about film and exposure, we are going to get the redscale film to look like it was originally intended.

Here is a quick glimpse at the problem:

In order to correct it, let us start with some theory where it all begins: at the exposure. Redscale is an ordinary colour print film, that is exposed from its back:

Colour dye-forming layers are shown as their complimentary colours (negative) for clarity. Some of the layers of the film structure are omitted for the same purpose.

In a “normal” exposure situation the blue-sensitive yellow layer is exposed first. The yellow filter behind it serves the purpose to remove the blue and UV light form the mixture, that hits the red- and green sensitive layers. The later are also sensitive to blue (as are all silver halides), so this filter is essential for correct colour balance in print film. We are however exposing our film from behind, which means that our red layer gets exposed first, but now it’s behind the antihalation layer, which attenuates the amount of light it sees, and behind that lovely transparent-orange film base that we all love.

Being shot without the blue-absorbing filter, our red-sensitive layer also becomes sensitive to blue, and hence the intense red cast all over the image frame. Our green-sensitive layer is to follow, but now it is behind the red-sensitive one, and gets less of that blue goodness, so the image turns a bit more yellow, but only in areas that have enough green and blue light to excite our green-sensitive halide crystals. Remember that in additive colour theory red light and green light give yellow when mixed:

The blue-sensitive layer is on the very bottom now, but wait, isn’t it behind both the blue-blocking layer and the orange film base? Well, it is, and it is the layer that gets least light from all. The blue light that it gets is so little that it really never shows up as a saturated colour (remember that our red layer really gets excited by both blue and red now), but it shines through in the most over-exposed areas of the frame, where it contributes to the white of the extreme highlights.

So, if we are to build a histogram for the perfect redscale shot, it would include reds everywhere, greens in most of the mildly over-exposed parts, and blue only in the extreme highlights:

Display the histogram by selecting Window→Dockable dialogs→Histogram and then select RGB in the small histogram window.

What if the scanning was sloppy? Well, we could get something like this:

Here all of the colour channels have un-equalized black points (the histogram doesn’t start from the left), which we are going to correct, but without cheating and changing our colour balance.

For the purpose of this tutorial, and in general too, I use GIMP.

It is an amazing peace of software. And it’s free. But don’t get carried away editing your photos, because the magic of the analogue will be lost.

We are going to use the Curves tool (find them in Colours→Curves) and fix each colour channel separately. Let us start with RED:

RED is where Redscale comes from, so we really want to make it shine, as it originally does would if it wasn’t for the sloppy scan. Make your curve (left bottom end) start where all of the exposure does. This is going to be our black point in the red channel. This particular one does not need the right (bright) end to be trimmed.

Let us continue with the GREEN channel. It is the second most predominant colour in our REDSCALE photo and it contributes on the YELLOW areas in the highlights:

Don’t get carried away, green must stay more on the left. Trim the black point like you did with the red, and trim a bit the “white” point too, until the mildly overexposed areas become yellow.

Now, the most absent colour of all: BLUE. It must stay strictly on the left, but its black point must still be trimmed:

Now, if we press OK, our inner redscale will shine:

So, according to our histogram we have a perfect redscale: Blue is on the left, red is on the right, and green in between.

written by adash on 2012-08-01 #gear #tutorials #colour #gimp #lomography #tipster #redscale #histogram #curves #color #tutorial #scanning #fix

19 Comments

  1. adam_g2000
    adam_g2000 ·

    I'm glad you wrote this, many people think editing anything you get back from a lab or your scanner should be where it ends but I personally think this sort of work is fine, because the minute you use a scanner, it's making digital choices and normally poor ones. I was very disappointed by the scans from mine, they seemed low in contrast and too far towards blue. Initially I thought it was my photos and until I decided to do something similar was disheartened. I will give this a thorough read and attempt to do something similar in Photoshop. In fact, another article like this for standard colour images that have scanned poorly would be appreciated!

  2. sixsixty
    sixsixty ·

    Very well written and intelligent article. Please write more.

  3. reminator
    reminator ·

    This is mighty handy, my first roll of redscale is going to the lab soon and I would be dissappointed if my scans came out dull.

  4. astilla
    astilla ·

    good article! :) most of my scanned redscales from the lab come out like the first picture. thanks for the tip!

  5. megzeazez
    megzeazez ·

    Wow, excellent article!

  6. dkersbergen
    dkersbergen ·

    Great article even though sloppy scans are part of Lomography ;)

  7. gatokinetik-o
    gatokinetik-o ·

    Well done... definitively i'll try it!

  8. abbsterocity
    abbsterocity ·

    Must try this!

  9. buckshot
    buckshot ·

    Aha...! Maybe *that's* why I don't like most of the redscale shots I get back from the lab! Will have to try your recommended tweaks... Thanks a lot!

  10. kneehigh85
    kneehigh85 ·

    Oh this is a great article - thanks a lot

  11. reminator
    reminator ·

    I had to re-do almost every scan I made, but it was quite easy when I got the hang of it. It's easy to see if there's a lot of blue and/or green and making it go away is even more easy. Worked trough the pics in no-time really!

  12. blu132
    blu132 ·

    this doesn't belong here, but this is the KDE desktop you are using, isn't it?

  13. jla
    jla ·

    @blu132 Those are not KDE window decorations, I believe that is GNOME 2.

  14. blacksburg25
    blacksburg25 ·

    thank you!

  15. clownshoes
    clownshoes ·

    Great stuff

  16. impaktor
    impaktor ·

    Nice! A big plus for using GIMP.
    @blu132 looks like a GTK based window decoration, like Gnome or XFCE, or no desktop environment at all.

  17. samwise_camus
    samwise_camus ·

    Thank you so much for this article! 1) I learned something about why redscale does what it does. 2) My redscale scans now look awesome, with all the blue noise reduced in the shadows.

  18. herbert-4
    herbert-4 ·

    Thanx!! I use GIMP when I must.

  19. sibu_sen
    sibu_sen ·

    Amazing article!!!

More Interesting Articles

  • Spontaneous Doubles with the XR Redscale Film

    written by hannah_brown on 2015-12-13 #tutorials
    Spontaneous Doubles with the XR Redscale Film

    I recently found a roll of XR Redscale 50-200 film lying around in my drawer and decided to reignite my passion for embracing the weird and unexpected results that film can bring. I shot random doubles around the streets of Soho and was rather delighted with the results.

    2015-12-13 1
  • LaserSoft Imaging’s SilverFast Brings Your Scans to Life (Part 1)

    written by Robn Kester on 2015-09-29 #gear #tutorials
    LaserSoft Imaging’s SilverFast Brings Your Scans to Life (Part 1)

    There is an assortment of applications you can use to scan your film, but I will tell you why you should be using SilverFast over all of the others. Its power is unrivaled, and once you get the hang of it, you will not want to go back.

    2015-09-29 11
  • Cameras in Depth: Handling a Rangefinder Camera

    written by sirio174 on 2016-08-15 #gear
    Cameras in Depth: Handling a Rangefinder Camera

    After my previous article dedicated to the comparison between pocket cameras, I'll write here about the ergonomics of some popular rangefinder cameras that I use, from the basic Soviet models to the finest Japanese cameras.

    2016-08-15 8
  • Shop News

    Celebrate summer with the Lomo'Instant San Sebastián

    Celebrate summer with the Lomo'Instant San Sebastián

    Walk along the sandy shore, take a dip and splash around, and celebrate summer with the Lomo'Instant San Sebastián! Inspired by the Spanish surf town, this nifty newest edition of the Lomo'Instant is perfect to capture your colorful instant summer snaps!

  • LaserSoft Imaging’s SilverFast Brings Your Scans to Life (Part 2)

    written by Robn Kester on 2015-09-30 #gear #tutorials
    LaserSoft Imaging’s SilverFast Brings Your Scans to Life (Part 2)

    There is an assortment of applications you can use to scan your film, but I will tell you why you should be using SilverFast over all of the others. Its power is unrivaled, and once you get the hang of it, you will not want to go back.

    2015-09-30 8
  • First Roll: Brunoroids with Lomochrome Purple Film! [NSFW]

    written by lomographynyc on 2016-09-14 #people
    First Roll: Brunoroids with Lomochrome Purple Film! [NSFW]

    When experimenting with new rolls of film, it's often the first roll that brings both the most joy and the most trial & tribulation. We want to start highlighting some successful first attempts here on our Magazine with our films. The first in this line up is Brian Bruno aka Brunoroids.

    2016-09-14
  • Film Format Fun: 126 Instamatic Film

    written by Maaike van Stratum (@stratski) on 2016-03-23 #gear #tutorials
    Film Format Fun: 126 Instamatic Film

    We all know about 35mm and 120 film, right? And since Lomography re-introduced 110 film, we have another film format to play with. But in the years past, many more film formats were in use. Let me introduce you to a few golden oldies and tell you about my experiences with them. Here's how I revived my Instamatic cameras.

    2016-03-23 8
  • Shop News

    Explore the New Jupiter 3+

    Explore the New Jupiter 3+

    A resurrection from the zenith of Russian premium optics, get the same elegance and classic compact design as its predecessor. — available in small quantities on a first-come, first-served basis.

  • Tipster: DIY X-Pro Redscale

    written by rancliffhasenza on 2015-09-27 #gear #tutorials
    Tipster: DIY X-Pro Redscale

    Browsing through the Lomography website, you can find a lot of redscale shots, which are all done on color negative films. I asked myself if it’s possible to redscale a slide or chrome film and then cross process it. (And yes, it is.) In this tipster I’m going to teach you how to create the bloodiest homemade redscale film I've ever come across.

    2015-09-27 10
  • Adam Eronen Piper: First Impressions of the Jupiter 3+ Art Lens

    written by lomographysoholondon on 2016-09-03 #news
    Adam Eronen Piper: First Impressions of the Jupiter 3+ Art Lens

    Finland based UK photographer Adam Eronen Piper shoots beautiful, minimal shots that evoke a sense of calm. We lent him the Jupiter 3+ lens which he used with a roll of colour film and his trusty Leica camera.

    2016-09-03
  • Memories and Mementos With the Smartphone Film Scanner

    written by Lomography on 2016-02-05 #news
    Memories and Mementos With the Smartphone Film Scanner

    Riffle through those embarrassing baby photos, search through snaps of grandma and grandpa, and revisit your parents' hilarious old haircuts! Round up your best family photographs and scan them with the Lomography Smartphone Film Scanner. To put you in a nostalgic mood, check out these photographs from the past 100 years that we found in our online community!

    2016-02-05
  • Shop News

    Introducing the Lomo'Instant Milano

    Introducing the Lomo'Instant Milano

    Named for the Italian city situated in the Lombardy region, overflowing with art and culture, say hello to the colorful aesthetics of the new Lomo'Instant Milano, the latest member of the Lomo'Instant family!

  • How to Develop Photos on Stone in a Darkroom

    written by tomas_bates on 2016-02-17 #gear #tutorials
    How to Develop Photos on Stone in a Darkroom

    I have always loved the idea of seeing my photos on stone and other natural materials. So, a few months ago, I began googling how it could be done. This is how I discovered (and fell in love with) liquid emulsion. Liquid emulsion is photographic emulsion which you can melt down and paint on any surface. You can then expose an image and develop it using traditional darkroom chemicals. In this article, I would like to explain the process a little, so that if you are also interested in giving this fun process a go, you can!

    2016-02-17 12
  • Julian Hand shoots with the LomoChrome Purple 16mm Film

    written by hannah_brown on 2015-11-17 #news #videos #tutorials
    Julian Hand shoots with the LomoChrome Purple 16mm Film

    Julian Hand is a London based experimental film maker. He embraces all analogue forms and uses Super 8 film, light projectors, ink and transparencies in his films. We gave him a roll of the new LomoChrome Purple 16mm Film to test out on the streets of London.

    2015-11-17
  • Tipster: Photo Scratch by ilcontrariodime

    written by bartolomo on 2016-02-18 #people #tutorials
    Tipster: Photo Scratch by ilcontrariodime

    We know that creativity has no limits and that you can never stop learning. Thanks to our community member, ilcontrariodime, we discovered how to hack films with anything that comes to mind, resulting in the photo scratch! This article explains how ilcontrariodime used this new technique.

    2016-02-18 3