To Infinity and beyond

4

Question: What’s bigger than bazillion? Answer: Infinity!!! But Infinity is one of those words that’s really hard to define – What exactly does it mean to say that something is Infinite? Is Infinity even a number?

What is Infinity?

Imagine that someone tries to get you to define infinity by asking you to name an infinitely big number – How should you answer?

999999999999999999?
9999999999999999999999999999?
9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999?

No, clearly none of these are infinitely big numbers! In fact, as soon as you try and say a specific number, there’s no way you can really be talking about something that is infinite – You can always just add another digit to what you’ve said to make it bigger. The problem reminds me of that game you play as a kid where you dare someone to do something (actually, come to think of it, I still play it now):

‘I dare you to do it’
‘I double dare you’
‘Too bad because I triple dare you’
‘You lose sucker – I dare you a million times!’
‘No you lose! I dare you infinity times’
‘Well I dare you to do 50 press-ups infinity times plus one – Beat that Grandad!!!’

So, if infinity isn’t a number, what is it? Well, people usually think about it as a concept instead. Infinity is something so big that it has no end. This is a pretty vague definition but, as we’ve seen, trying to pin things down leads to problems!

Achilles and the Tortoise

One of the first Philosophers to look at the concept of infinity in detail was Zeno of Elea. Zeno lived in Ancient Greece from c. 490 BC until c. 430 BC. He told several paradoxical stories about infinity and the story of Achilles and the Tortoise is one of them:

Imagine that Achilles is having a race against his slowest friend, Mr. Tortoise. Because Achilles is so confident that he’ll win the race, he gives the tortoise a head-start of 100 meters. So the race begins and both Achilles and Mr. Tortoise run as fast as they can. After a little time, Achilles has run 100 meters. But during this time, Mr. Tortoise moves forward a little too (we’ll say 10 meters). Now imagine that Achilles runs the next 10 meters to catch up with the tortoise – But by the time he has run this distance, Mr. Tortoise will have moved a little farther on again. And because this process can go on and on, it looks like however far Achilles runs, he will never catch up with the tortoise – It will always take Achilles some time to reach the point where Mr. Tortoise was before, and by the time he reaches that last point, the tortoise will have moved on a little bit! So the story states that while the gap between Achilles and the tortoise might get smaller and smaller, Achilles will never be able to catch up with his green-shelled friend!

Whilst it may not be clear straightaway, the problem Zeno expresses in his story relates to the concept of infinity – Namely, the problem involves Achilles trying to complete an infinite number of tasks in order to catch up with the tortoise. By the time Achilles reaches point 1 (the point at which the tortoise starts the race), the tortoise will have reached point 2. And by the time Achilles reaches point 2, the tortoise will be at point 3. And by the time Achilles reaches point 3, the tortoise will already be at point 4. And so on to infinity. So, in the story, it looks like Achilles must somehow complete an infinite number of steps (reaching points 1, 2, 3 etc.) in order to catch up with his friend.

But Zeno’s story is clearly absurd – We all know that Achilles would easily be able to catch up with the tortoise in real life! So what’s wrong with the story? Post your answers in the comments below, I need your help and infinite wisdom to answer this paradox!

Prophecy Number 9: ‘A bazillion fresh analogue tunes await us’ – Want to learn more about the analogue future? Head to the Microsite, take part in our Shoot Your Prophecy Competition and download the Future is Analogue posters!

written by tomas_bates on 2011-04-22 in #lifestyle #infinity #future #analogue #beyond #prophecies #paradox

4 Comments

1. carmenism ·

Interesting article. There is the obvious fact that the tortoise would have to be moving at a speed greater than or equal to Achille's fastest running speed (which is not possible unless Achilles is quite slow or the turtle is quite fast). And of course no person or animal could take an infinite number of steps except in a riddle; people get hungry or tired or die, so the number of steps one will take is finite.

But anyway, I don't think the story describes infinity as much as it describes a limit. A limit is an infinite series, but it is quite possible for an infinite series to converge at a finite number. A function may have its limit at infinity, though not necessarily. Here I would definitely say this limit converges at a finite number. I think the paradox is trying to talk about how if you divide a space forever then it can tricky to determine what the sum of those divisions is. For example, (1/2)+(1/4)+(1/8)+(1/16)+... actually sums to 1!

Say Achilles moves 10 times faster than the tortoise. So when Achilles has moved 10 meters from the starting point, the tortoise has moved only 1 meter, though he'll be 100+1=101 meters from the starting point, so the distance between them is 101-10=91 meters. When Achilles has moved 100 meters from the starting point, the tortoise will have moved only 10 meters, placing the tortoise 100+10 meters from these starting point. Then the distance between them is 110-100=10. As Achilles moves another 10 meters (placing him 110 meters from the starting point), the tortoise will move only 1 meter (placing him 111 meters from the starting point). Then the distance between them is 111-110=1 meter. As Achilles runs 1 meter ahead (now 111 meters from start), then the tortoise moves (1/10) meter (now 111.1 meters from the start), so the distance between is 111.1-111=0.1 meter. So it seems like he will never catch up. However, when Achilles runs 10 meters at that point in time, the tortoise moves only 1 meter, so the difference is 112.1-121=-8.9 meters. In other words, Achilles is ahead!

So the distance Achilles must travel to catch up is 100 + 10 + 1 + 0.1 + 0.01 + ... + 10^(2-n) + ... where n is the number of seconds, which sums to 111.11m! He needs to travel a finite distance to catch up. So he is set as long as the track is at least 111.11 meters long.

Here is another way of looking at it... It is reasonable to assume both the paces of Achilles and the tortoise will not increase as they get tired, so it is safe to assume that both are moving at a constant speed. Say Achilles is moves taking one steps per second where each step is 1 meter. Say the tortoise moves only one step per second and moves only (1/10) meter. So in n seconds, Achilles has moved n meters, while the tortoise has moved only (1/10)*n meters. Since the tortoise received a head start, the distance he has covered in n seconds is f(n) = 100 + (1/10)*n. The distance Achilles will cover in n seconds is g(n) = n. Set f(n) = g(n) to see when they converge and you'll find n = (1000/9) seconds. So, after 1000/9 seconds, Achilles will pass the tortoise. He will have moved (1000/9) = 111.11 meters in that time, so if the track is longer than that distance, he will win for certain!

2. basho ·

@carmenism: OMG! :O

3. tomas_bates ·

@carmenism - thanks a lot for your thoughts on this, very cool ideas :-)

4. stouf ·

@carmenism: Impressive ! And you should send your CV to the NASA ! : ))) And you're perfectly right... Hum I believe you... : )
But maybe Zeno was trying to say that even looking infinitely closely at the moment Achilles beats the tortoise, he's still behind. Maybe ?

More Interesting Articles

• Elliott Erwitt's Contact Sheets

written by Julien Matabuena on 2015-06-05 in #world #lifestyle #videos

"If there's one thing photographers must never ever do, it is to show their contact sheets or to display them in public," says the esteemed photographer, who does exactly that in this short clip.

• How the Very First Commercial Instant Camera Came to Be

written by lomographymagazine on 2015-11-19 in #world #lifestyle

Children, ever curious and with an innate sense of wonder, ask a lot of questions. Often they're easy enough to answer, but sometimes there are those that leave the adults stumped and mulling over them. The history of the instant camera as we know it began with one such question.

• Self to the World: The Photography of Leanne Surfleet

written by lomographymagazine on 2015-11-17 in #people #lifestyle

A self-portrait may take root in confidence, extreme shyness or alternate bouts of each. Leanne Surfleet goes through this kind of fluctuation when the camera is all eyes. The attraction—as far as we’re concerned—is the mix of uncertainty and a kind of quiet poise. And here and there, a flash of skin that is more a mystery than full-on revelation. Even Surfleet’s portraits of other people have the same hushed invite, as if to say questions are encouraged. There we took our cue.

Ondu 4X5 Large Format Pinhole Camera

Want to push your limits in the field of photography? Go large format! This camera uses a 4x5” film and can capture all the subjects you want with this pinhole camera in large format!

• Photo of the Day by _baunovart_

written by lomography on 2016-02-06 in #world #news

It took nearly 20 years for this work of art to be completed.

1
• Landei and her Weapon of Choice: Sprocket Rocket

written by lomography on 2016-02-06 in #world

Lomographer Carina, or landei in the community, regards the Sprocket Rocket as a "versatile plastic camera." For her, it doesn't only take great travel snapshots but makes an interesting conversation starter as well. In this interview, Carina expounds more on what makes the Sprocket Rocket her go-to camera.

2
• Inside the Closed World of State Mental Hospitals

written by Lomography on 2016-02-06 in #people #locations

Architectural photographer Christopher Payne takes us on a historical journey through the abandoned psychiatric hospitals that were once a distinctive feature of the American landscape.

2

Give your space a facelift with your own analogue print

Really want to bring your film photos to life? We’re now offering totally analogue fine art prints in a host of large sizes and formats! Carefully enlarged from your negatives onto premium photographic paper by lab professionals, each picture is a unique piece of craftsmanship.

• Lubitel Is Back In Stock

written by lomographymagazine on 2016-02-06 in #gear #news

No need to miss Lubitel this Valentine's, you budding camera collector. The Lomography Shop is fully stocked with the twin-lens classic.

1
• Djdhmikey25 is our LomoHome of the Day!

written by lomography on 2016-02-06 in #world #news

From everyone here in Lomography, congratualtions to djdhmikey25 for winning Home of the Day!

• A Salute to the Masters: Santa Barbara 2015 (A Tribute to Bruce Davidson)

written by sirio174 on 2016-02-06 in #world #lifestyle

This article is dedicated to Bruce Davidson, one of the most important American documentary photographers and a leading figure of the Magnum agency. Recalling his photos of the Worcester Fire Department in 1999, I'll show you my coverage of Como Fire Department's public demonstration, an annual event commemorating St. Barbara.

The Lomography Experimental Lens Kit opens up a new, creative photographic domain!

Satisfy your hunger for creative snap-shooting with this lens package made especially for Micro 4/3 digital cameras! Don't miss the 20% discount!

• Robertofiuza is our LomoHome of the Day!

written by lomography on 2016-02-05 in #world

From everyone here in Lomography, congratulation to robertofiuza for winning Home of the Day!

6
• Lomography Online Shop Introduces Category Filters for Easier Film Shopping

written by lomographymagazine on 2016-02-05 in #gear #news

Sure, it takes effort to source films these days, but the Lomography Shop has just made the online part more convenient.

1
• Just In: Get Camera Discounts via Lomography's Early Bird Valentine's Day Deal

written by lomographymagazine on 2016-02-05 in #gear #news

In the name of analogue love, the Lomography Shop is now offering great discounts on handy cameras.