What is Art? What is Beauty?

5

We asked Robert Hopkins, President of the European Society for Aesthetics, for his thoughts on these and other questions - Read on for his answers!

Is it possible to define what ‘Art’ is?

I think we’d have to concede that a satisfactory definition has yet to be found. The traditional attempts to define art – as representation, or as the expression of emotion or as whatever is made to repay aesthetic attention – all seem to fail to fit some or other important artwork, or even whole genres or artforms. And more recent attempts to capture art’s essence in sociological terms (more or less, the idea that art is whatever the relevant authorities accept as art) arguably don’t really tell us very much. Some have taken all this to show that art cannot be defined: it is by its very nature too protean, too exploratory and fluid, ever to be captured in a formula. However, it’s not clear that art is harder to define than other concepts. (Try truth, or knowledge, or doing what one ought.) All our most interesting and important ideas resist definition.

Is Beauty only in the eye of the beholder?

Well, what’s the alternative? If the only other option is that beauty is ‘in’ the thing we find beautiful then – assuming we can make sense of this talk of properties being in places at all – I’ll go for the beholder’s eye. But consider colours. Are they ‘in’ objects or ‘in’ the eye of those who see them? That looks like a false choice. Colours may not be fundamental features of the world, the way that shapes or mass are. But nor are they mere fantasms. We can make mistakes about the colour of things (think of colour-blind people, or seeing something in an unsuitable light), and that’s enough for our judgements of colour to have some kind of objectivity. And, although there are complications here, I think things are much the same with beauty. It may not be part of the fundamental furniture of the universe, but nor is it simply something individuals impose on the world.

What makes Photographs special?

Photographs are pictures, and so are special in the way that all pictures are. But photographs are pictures of a special kind. What is special about them, versus other pictures? I’m sympathetic to the thought, which I’ve heard various photographers endorse, that photos are ‘traces’, while other pictures are ‘signs’. What does that mean, though? I think that what distinguishes photographs is that the way they show the world to be depends on how it was, without depending on how the photographer took it to be. That’s not true for other pictures: even when they are accurate, they are so only because the artist sought to show how things are, and herself saw the world accurately. Of course, there are complexities here, to do with the very considerable control the photographer does have over the image. Still, I think those don’t, in the end, alter the underlying facts.

Why do we care about Art?

A good question! One striking feature of most accounts of what art is, is that they completely fail to explain why we’d value it. That’s certainly true of most of the theories I mentioned above – though an honourable exception here is the view that art is expressive, at least as that view was developed by the 20th century English philosopher R.G.Collingwood. Perhaps there is simply nothing, at the utterly general level, to be said about art’s value. Perhaps, in other words, we should start instead by asking why we care about this painting, or that piece of music; or perhaps by asking what there is to care about in (say) painting in general that is not available in music, and vice versa. The deity might be in the detail, if you’ll allow me the pun.

Why do people care that an artwork is an original rather than a forgery?

It’s not really a philosopher’s job to say why in fact people care. However, it is my job to explore why they should care – to find the differences between originals and forgeries that might make it reasonable to prefer the former. The question only really gets interesting if we imagine that the forgery is perfect, i.e. so good that no matter how long one looks, or how expert one’s eye, one will not be able to tell it from the original. Even so, the original will have properties the forgery lacks. The original might, for example, be ground-breaking as art; the forgery can at most be ground-breaking as a copy. In a way, it’s obvious that there can be this sort of difference between the two. So, since I think we all worry that there might really be an issue about whether it’s rational to prefer the original, the question becomes why we might think that these differences somehow don’t count. The answer can only lie in the thought that what is valuable in an artwork must show up in our experience of it. Can the ground-breaking nature of the original do this, even though the indistinguishable forgery lacks that feature? Perhaps surprisingly, I think it can – though I’d need more space than we’ve got here to explain quite how.

Robert Hopkins is the President of the European Society for Aesthetics and Head of Philosophy at The University of Sheffield in the UK.

Want to bring real life beauty back? Head to the Microsite, take part in our Shoot Your Prophecy Competition and download the Future is Analogue posters!

written by tomas_bates on 2011-03-18 in #lifestyle #philosophy #art #analogue #beauty #future

5 Comments

  1. neja
    neja ·

    herr Willie!!!!

  2. ali55
    ali55 ·

    very interesting :)

  3. cyan-shine
    cyan-shine ·

    Wow, some great images with this article, but where are the photographer credits??????????

  4. juxtimon
    juxtimon ·

    interesting article :)

  5. coryk0303
    coryk0303 ·

    great way to start the morning !

More Interesting Articles

  • A Chat with the Founder of STENOFLEX, Eric Marais

    written by jacobs on 2015-03-04 in #people #lifestyle
    A Chat with the Founder of STENOFLEX, Eric Marais

    Eric Marais is the founder of the portable dark-room experience, STENOFLEX. We recently had the chance to ask him some questions and he was kind enough to answer us! Read on to find out more about his company, his interest in photography and what's next for STENOFLEX!

    1
  • 'Soundcheck Sessions': Stephen Dowling's Exhibition

    written by gise11e on 2015-05-04 in #people #news #events
    'Soundcheck Sessions': Stephen Dowling's Exhibition

    Stephen Dowling is a photojournalist and longterm LomoAmigo who is presenting his series, "Soundcheck Sessions," as his first exhibition for Lomography this month. In an interview, we asked him a few questions about his work and what goes on behind the scenes.

  • Christopher Logan's First Impression of the New Petzval 58 Bokeh Control Art Lens

    written by Jill Tan Radovan on 2015-06-12 in #people
    Christopher Logan's First Impression of the New Petzval 58 Bokeh Control Art Lens

    Years ago, a young Christopher Logan moved to Milan after obtaining a Photography degree from The Art Institute of Fort Lauderdale. Falling in love with the European aesthetic which would later manifest in his photos, he was commissioned by a number of fashion houses, further developing his craft. He is now based in yet another fashion capital - New York City - and is still immersed in the world of fashion.

    1
  • Shop News

    Lomo'Instant Reykjavik Edition

    Lomo'Instant Reykjavik Edition

    The latest addition to the Lomo’Instant family! Inspired by the Icelandic midnight sky, Get endless creativity, take multiple exposed instant snapshots, experiment with long exposure and light painting shots!

  • How the Very First Commercial Instant Camera Came to Be

    written by lomographymagazine on 2015-11-19 in #world #lifestyle
    How the Very First Commercial Instant Camera Came to Be

    Children, ever curious and with an innate sense of wonder, ask a lot of questions. Often they're easy enough to answer, but sometimes there are those that leave the adults stumped and mulling over them. The history of the instant camera as we know it began with one such question.

  • LomoAmigos: These Ghosts

    written by hannah_brown on 2015-04-13 in #people #lomoamigos
    LomoAmigos: These Ghosts

    Norfolk-based, three-piece band These Ghosts are analog mad! We gave them a Sprocket Rocket camera to document their latest tour with and asked them about their love for film photography. Read on for the full interview.

  • Petzval Amigo: Davie Tidd

    written by hannah_brown on 2015-04-01 in #people #lomoamigos
    Petzval Amigo: Davie Tidd

    We lent David Tidd a Petzval Art Lens to test its full potential. He gave us some tips on how to get the most out of this beautiful portrait lens. Read on for the full interview.

  • Shop News

    Ondu 4X5 Large Format Pinhole Camera

    Ondu 4X5 Large Format Pinhole Camera

    Want to push your limits in the field of photography? Go large format! This camera uses a 4x5” film and can capture all the subjects you want with this pinhole camera in large format!

  • Serendipity Exhibition by Toby Mason

    written by lomographysoholondon on 2015-09-10 in #world #events
    Serendipity Exhibition by Toby Mason

    Toby Mason (aka fotobes) is a Brighton-based photographer who embraces the aesthetics of film photography. He mostly shoots with the LC-A+ using a range of slide films, cross processing them to create rich, highly saturated colours. His work has been featured on the BBC website and Hungry Eye Magazine. Join us for the opening night on Thursday, September 17 from 6 p.m.

    2
  • Petzval Artist: The Aesthetics Of Photographer Issa Ng

    written by lomographygallerystorehk on 2015-07-02 in #people #lifestyle #reviews
    Petzval Artist: The Aesthetics Of Photographer Issa Ng

    As a photographer, Issa Ng is known for his expertise in portraiture and fashion photography. Having worked with different international brands as an Art Director, he has developed a great sense for aesthetics and details, which are reflected in his work. For the past three years thePetzval lens has been part of his workflow, and it has helped him create those show-stopping fashion portraits.

  • Coloring Outside the Lines with LomoAmigo Tim Kerr

    written by jacobs on 2015-02-16 in #people #lomoamigos
    Coloring Outside the Lines with LomoAmigo Tim Kerr

    We recently had the great opportunity to interview our latest LomoAmigo, Tim Kerr. While his repertoire stretches back to the late 1970's and includes that of musician, artist, painter, photographer, skater and many other things, he just prefers Tim! We gave him a La Sardina DIY, which he not only added his own style to, but shot some excellent photos with as well. Rife with candid and thoughtful answers, we expect everyone will glean a nugget of wisdom and leave with a smile.

  • Shop News

    Try the LomoLAB Development Service!

    Try the LomoLAB Development Service!

    Whatever kind of film development you're after, you'll find it here! Now you can confidently shoot from the hip without having to worry where to develop those film rolls!

  • Petzval 58 Amigo: Benjamin Kracke

    written by Lomography on 2016-02-10 in #people #news #lomoamigos
    Petzval 58 Amigo: Benjamin Kracke

    Germany-based Benjamin Kracke began his photography journey by searching for something unique. Naturally, the New Petzval 58 Bokeh Control Art Lens proved to be full of character for this LomoAmigo! Read on to find out more about his experience with this beautiful art lens.

  • LomoAmigo: Paul White

    written by hannah_brown on 2015-04-20 in #people #lomoamigos
    LomoAmigo: Paul White

    Paul White is a South East London-based hip-hop producer with tons of energy and a penchant for film photography. He recently released his fifth album on the mighty R&S label. We decided to arm him with a Sprocket Rocket to shoot his adventures with. Read the full interview and see his images here.

  • Photo of the Day by mavicomeflor

    written by lomography on 2016-02-13 in #world #news
    Photo of the Day by mavicomeflor

    It's never too early to plan for your summer escapade. Here's another must-visit destination in the Caribbean as photographed by our fellow lomographer.