Picking the Winners

19

Picking winners is never easy, and we understand that some of you may question our choice of winners at time, some of you hinting that we have a random system in place doing the work for us. We have also seen several comments recently that many of the winning pictures are good but do not fit the theme of the competition and that submissions are winning that do not meet requirements. That’s why we thought we could take some time and answer some questions.

Picking winners is never easy, and we understand that some of you may question our choice of winners at time, some of you hinting that we have a random system in place doing the work for us. We have also seen several comments recently that many of the winning pictures are good but do not fit the theme of the competition and that submissions are winning that do not meet requirements. That’s why we thought we could take some time and answer some questions.

For each competition that is held on Lomography.com, be it 24 hour rumbles or larger corporations with outside partners such as Urban Outfitters, there is always a jury picking the winning shots. A jury depends on the size of the competition (larger for larger competitions) but there are always at least 2 people at LSI choosing winners, (for daily rumbles, otherwise more). A jury is human, and humans by nature focus on different aspects in photos. Please bear in mind that while the jury tries to be objective, a jury by definition will have some subjective influence.

Winning shots are not picked by a random generator. The jury looks at the submissions, each member makes a short list of his favorites which is then combined. From the final list the jury then votes on the pictures and the winning shots are picked. In the case that a certain photo gets an equal amount of votes then those pictures are voted on again.

Regarding some of your questions as to pictures winning that do not match the theme of the competition, we try to choose a picture that fits the theme sometimes in a broader sense.

As to pictures being submitted that do not meet the requirements of the competition, we have stated in the FAQ that we can not make sure all pictures meet the requirements, this would then take hours of work looking at each picture in great detail. If a picture obviously does not meet the requirement we disregard those. We trust, you, the community, to submit only pictures that meet the requirements and are authentic.

For Lomo Home Of the Day there are certain requirements that a home must be fulfill before being shortlisted before a jury. The home owner should have submitted lomolocation tips and have a minimum of 10 albums. It also helps to have entered a competition, have filled out their lomowall and then submitted their lomohome for the competition. After this, a jury manually picks a home. Of course, exceptions do occur as some homes are absolutely stunning and even though they do not meet all the requirements we award such homes. Be happy for the winner!

An Oktokino award is given and chosen daily by a jury. The jury looks at many movies a day choosing what they think is the best submission. The jury looks for dynamic pieces and pieces that make sense.

OSCM winners are chosen through two main filters, the first filter brings the submission here where they are then eligible for winning the OSCM award. Once there, a jury selects the daily winner.

And now to another subject that many of you have asked about: camera, film and location submissions. We often get questions asking if a submission was not good enough as it has not been published. In order to keep the magazine regularly updated with articles in all sections we may choose keep some of your submissions offline for a while. We also try to give reviews that are written by “new” (those that have not previously submitted entries) members an advantage as we want to encourage diversity. Hence if you submit three reviews and only one get published it does not mean that your other two reviews were bad. It simply means that we have kept them for later use.

Likewise, we do not want to publish to like reviews after another. Hence if we get two reviews for the Diana we would like to publish something in between the two to give diversity. It may happen that we at times make call outs, such as the film class, where we ask for specific reviews. In such cases we will feature those reviews ahead of others that may have been in the inbox longer.

All in all, if you follow the guidelines (camera, locations) your submissions will get published sooner or later. If we see that a review is good save for one aspect (for example missing pictures) we try to contact you to have these added.

We hope that this clarifies some questions!

written by lucasjakobsson on 2008-09-19 in #news

19 Comments

  1. hanspan
    hanspan ·

    no objections at all - i think you all do a great job to run as many rumbles and things to keep us occupied - you don't have to do any of it!

    much appreciated!!!!!

  2. mattcharnock
    mattcharnock ·

    For me I realised somehting only recently, I just really like enetering the competitions - and what i really like is the shoot for a competition - if it wins a prize then that is great if not then I still have some images that I perhaps would have taken. I realise that this sounds sanctamonious and sometimes I am unsure as to why a shot wins (my own shots included in that) But i think we ahve to look at it from a slightly different angle - if the competitions wernt there would we still be addicted to analogue and the answer is yes - the piggies just make it sweeter. I realise this rambles but i have had a lot of coffee today and am shaking a little (cue slightly manic laugh)

  3. tmmluis
    tmmluis ·

    Hello guys, your text is very clear. Sometimes at the beginning I was frustrated too with some winners but I realised the fun comes not from winning but from shooting! ;-)

  4. kazarareta
    kazarareta ·

    have a great weekend everyone! leave a message if there seems to be anything needed to be clarified still. :) this new FAQ is the staff's blood, sweat and tears!

  5. tommynorth
    tommynorth ·

    all seems fine and dandy, although i would like to win a competition so if you can set up a rumble that can only be entered by me it would be much appreciated. : ).

    I am amazed every time i see other peoples shots, especially the double exposure ones, those were amazing, i love the beach one that won

  6. tmmluis
    tmmluis ·

    Great weekend to you too!
    If you were Portuguese I would invite you to dinner and drink, maybe next time... ;-)

  7. kazarareta
    kazarareta ·

    @tmmluis: thanks for the offer! maybe if you happen to fly by manila you could meet some of us as well!

  8. jackievision
    jackievision ·

    this was very nice from you guys, thanks. :)

  9. kylethefrench
    kylethefrench ·

    Nice clarification, I know I had been a main instigatior speciafficaly about the urban nomad requirements but I just want to say that I always always always enjoy the winning shots and the diversity and quality of those in the LSI community... also that I am so appreciative off all the prizes and piggies. I just had the teacher in me feeling all enraged when the stated requirements or stated procedures weren't followed in contests---but now that you all are being so clear about how things work and am assuming that this will continue in the future and at the start of a contest(like the great job you did with the redscale requirements) I withdraw any complaints--- ultimately you guys and gals do a great job over there, keep it up

  10. mephisto19
    mephisto19 ·

    thank you lsi for this here
    i have been complaining a lot, i know. but i really did not understand some urban nomad winning shots.

    have a nice weekend

  11. anarchy
    anarchy ·

    Firstly, I want to wish everyone at LSI a wonderful weekend too!

    Secondly, I have no complaints at all regarding the competitions, but thanks a lot for clarifying the process behind it all.

    You are doing a GREAT job and all these competitions/rumbles/call-out's fuel me with inspiration to be a better and more creative photographer. For that I am eternally grateful.

    The possibiities to interact with the Lomographic community are virtually endless and that is what keeps this site alive and kicking... On a side note: I will never understand how you guys manage to tie this all together and re-invent yourself again and again...

    Much respect and love!
    /Andreas

  12. jeepeng
    jeepeng ·

    always be there with you, LSI

    with love,
    jeep

  13. johann_affendy
    johann_affendy ·

    i'm not one to complain since LSI has been very good to me but honestly i was quite disappointed with the urban nomad results. your clarification helped me ease up a bit, for that you have my thanks. keep up the good work guys!

  14. ipdegirl
    ipdegirl ·

    Thanks so much for all the clarifications. I had no idea you had to actually submit your home for LHOTD. That helps alot!! Keep up all the hard work!

  15. mattdude1081
    mattdude1081 ·

    hey, I love you guys and gals

  16. weechonghooi
    weechonghooi ·

    I am in neutral side.. sometimes i think when a winning shots doesnt meet the requirement, but I dun mind taking it as a challenge to push me a step forward. LSI is always good and friendly..

    Hooi =)

  17. dirklancer
    dirklancer ·

    I'm still pretty new here - but I must say, so much of this is pure inspiration. keep it up!! :)

  18. notcub
    notcub ·

    oh good

  19. drudolph
    drudolph ·

    This helps a lot. Thanks LSI.

    Going to go get my home in order so I can someday be Home-of-the-Day!

More Interesting Articles

  • Debbie Carlos Competition Winners

    written by hannah_brown on 2014-05-02 in #news
    Debbie Carlos Competition Winners

    We have looked through all the photo submission for this competition and picked three winners who will all get a signed black-and-white print from photographer Debbie Carlos. He are the winners.

    2
  • We Were Evergreen Rumble Winners Announced

    written by hannah_brown on 2014-05-12 in #news
    We Were Evergreen Rumble Winners Announced

    We received hundreds of your green-themed photos and have now picked the three winning photographs. Could yours be one of them? Find out right now!

    2
  • Tatty Devine X Lomography Rumble WINNERS

    written by hannah_brown on 2015-01-13 in #news
    Tatty Devine X Lomography Rumble WINNERS

    We've been picking our way through all the submissions of the Tatty Devine x Lomography rumble. After much deliberation, we have chosen three winners.

  • Shop News

    Full Focus on the Framing

    Full Focus on the Framing

    Shooting with the Lubitel 166+ is an experience on it´s own. The waist level finder will help you to compose your frames perfectly.With the possibility to use 120 and 35mm Film It offers unlimited creative possibilities deemed to be an analogue masterpiece. Get your legendary Lubitel 166+ in our Online Shop!

  • Helena Carrington Rumble Winner Announcement

    written by hannah_brown on 2014-06-19 in #news
    Helena Carrington Rumble Winner Announcement

    Just last month, we gave you the opportunity to win beautifully illustrated goodies from UK-based illustrator Helena Carrington. From over 1000 entries, Helena herself has personally picked her Top 3 images and we are happy to announce the winners of Helena Carrington notebooks and cushions.

    4
  • The Magic Yet To Come: Part 4

    written by Lomography on 2014-09-05 in #news
    The Magic Yet To Come: Part 4

    Read on dear friend and I will weave a story for you. There may be more questions than answers raised by this peculiar tale. But if it’s clarity you seek, have no fear, things will become clear in time (they always do, don’t they?). So rub the Sandman’s dust from your sleepy eyes and take a journey with me. If you think you have an answer when we reach the end, please do share it in the comments!

    8
  • Lomography X Warp Flying Lotus Winners announced!

    written by hannah_brown on 2014-11-27 in #news
    Lomography X Warp Flying Lotus Winners announced!

    We had a huge response from this competition and quite rightly so, I mean who wouldn't want the chance to win a copy of the new Flying Lotus album? Anyway, we've picked our way through them all and chosen the best three. Find out who has won here.

  • Shop News

    Change the View in an Instant

    Change the View in an Instant

    Extend the Borders of Instant Photography with the World’s Most Creative Instant Camera System Packed With Fun Features and say hello to the Lomo'Instant Camera! The Lomo'Instant is the perfectly sized Instant Camera to take wherever you go! It’s the most creative way to shoot fantastic photos which you can share anywhere and with everyone in an instant.

  • Lomography and caseable - Best Shots of 2013 Winner Announcement

    written by zonderbar on 2014-04-22 in #competitions
    Lomography and caseable - Best Shots of 2013 Winner Announcement

    We sought for your best shots from the past year and received a staggering amount of more than 2,200 beautiful submissions within one month! It took a while to carefully go through all of the amazing analogue entries, and we have finally selected 3 lucky winners of the Lomography and caseable - Best Shots of 2013 Competition.

    10
  • Lomography x National Portrait Gallery Rumble WINNERS!

    written by hannah_brown on 2015-01-06 in #news
    Lomography x National Portrait Gallery Rumble WINNERS!

    We had a staggering 1110 entries to this rumble. We have picked our way through all of them and were very inspired by the quality of all your photos! It was a real challenge narrowing it down to just 3 winners. Find out who won this great competition.

    1
  • The Comment Your Caption Rumble: My Funny Furry Friends Winners Announcement

    written by icequeenubia on 2014-04-29 in #competitions
    The Comment Your Caption Rumble: My Funny Furry Friends Winners Announcement

    True, they are our loyal companions, but sometimes these cats and dogs just do these adorable, unexpected things that are really hard not to make fun of!

    3
  • Shop News

    Carry your Cameras with Style

    Carry your Cameras with Style

    No matter what size or cut - the ZKIN bags will always securely hold your cameras, accessories and personal things. Find the right one for you still today and never hustle with digging out photo gear from the deep, dark and dangerous corners of your regular bags!

  • Robertofiuza and His Weapon of Choice: Lomography Color Negative 400

    written by icequeenubia on 2014-03-06 in #lifestyle
    Robertofiuza and His Weapon of Choice: Lomography Color Negative 400

    Roberto wanted to get redscale films during his visit to a Lomography shop in Amsterdam. Due to some twist of fate, the shop did not have stocks of it at that time. So, he ended getting rolls of Lomography Color Negative 400 instead. Little did he know, this film is what he exactly needs to have a complete Lomography experience. Read on to find out more about robertofiuza and his Weapon of Choice - Lomography Color Negative 400!

    3
  • Exploring the joy of “Now”

    written by cheeo on 2014-05-07 in #lifestyle
    Exploring the joy of “Now”

    Have you ever had the feeling that you plan too much? It’s not a bad thing, really. It’s just that you may be missing out on some of the greater things happening at the precise moment you’re plotting your schedule, and you’re missing a lot if all you do is plan all the time.

  • KOMONO X Lomography: Conceptions of Time Winner Announcement

    written by natalieachao on 2014-07-11 in #competitions
    KOMONO X Lomography: Conceptions of Time Winner Announcement

    Time is a mysterious notion, one that is subjectively defined by each individual. We asked you to encapsulate your own perception of time in the form of Lomographs, and now we've decided the winners!

    3