The Iconic Napalm Girl Photo Uncropped

3

We've all seen the gripping and iconic image photographer Nick Ut took of "Napalm Girl" Kim Phuc. But have you seen it uncropped? We have it here!

Let’s see both photos first:

Photo by Nick Ut – cropped
Photo by Nick Ut – uncropped

This photo is one of the most iconic photos of our time. It captured perfectly the brutality and senselessness of war.

But as photographers, let’s take a step back and look at the two images. Do you feel that the crop was done for simplicity’s sake? Or was it done to make the image more powerful? Or could it have been the image of a photographer changing rolls while children are running around screaming is in poor taste? I’ll go ahead and give a disclaimer that there’s no right or wrong answers – we’re in here just for discussion’s sake. Let’s keep it civil and objective.

In any case, let us know in the comments what you think!

written by cruzron on 2013-09-27 in #lifestyle #napalm #vietnam #war #photography #history #documentary

3 Comments

  1. superlighter
    superlighter ·

    Well, for me is very difficult to remain civil and objective in front of this image, I think that the uncropped version is also more terrible (if this is possible) for the presence of the photographer on the right, however, in my opinion, words are useless in some case.

  2. wreckingpress
    wreckingpress ·

    Nam was a strangely covered war in that for the first time moving images of this "hell" are introduced on television. When the second Iraq war happened and my friends and I were all wowed by coverage. my father noted he had seen enough growing up during that time. quickly the novelty of the coverage wore off and the reality of the humanity and lack thereof sets in.

    I get the editor/photographer decision to crop the other photographer out. It is distracting and brings the focus back onto the children and soldiers. Its reason to being such an iconic image is its desperation, terror, and the shock value.

  3. holgardo
    holgardo ·

    I think there is a simple, direct, almost objectie answer to the question: when cropping the image, Kim Phuc becomes the phisical center of the image (she is allready the emotional center of it), so in terms of compostion the cropped one is a stringer image.
    There is another answer, or maybe another question. Is the documental value of the image cropped by cropping the image?

More Interesting Articles

  • The Magic Yet To Come: Part 5

    written by Lomography on 2014-09-06 in #news
    The Magic Yet To Come: Part 5

    Last week, I received the strangest thing through my letterbox. It was a postcard with this photograph on 1 side. The photo is of me sitting by the sea whilst I was on vacation last year. But I have literally no idea who took this shot – That’s why I came here, to ask for your help on my search for my mysterious photographer and to try and get to bottom of the riddle they wrote me. Please help me if you can!

    10
  • What Photography and Tech Websites are Saying About the New LC-A 120

    written by chooolss on 2014-09-25 in #news
    What Photography and Tech Websites are Saying About the New LC-A 120

    It's only been a few weeks since we launched the newest member of the LC-A family, yet the Internet has already been abuzz with much talk about it. We're thrilled to see all the coverage that photography and tech websites and blogs have given the LC-A 120, so we've rounded up some of them to share with you right here!

  • Friday, Feed and Friends

    written by recurving on 2015-02-27 in #world #news
    Friday, Feed and Friends

    Today we've put two beloved features online again: the feed and your friends. How does it work? You follow other photographers here and every photo they share is then shown in your feed. That's it.

    19
  • Shop News

    Shoot recognizable images with the Petzval

    Shoot recognizable images with the Petzval

    You want your subject be the center of attention? Petzval lens photos are recognizable for sharpness and crispness in the centre, strong color saturation, wonderful swirly bokeh effect, artful vignettes and narrow depth of field that will make your subjects stand out!

  • Photo of the Day by catfordst

    written by cheeo on 2014-12-19 in #news
    Photo of the Day by catfordst

    Tired after a long photowalk, she imagines one of the views she had seen and took a photograph of.

    2
  • The Invisible Photograph's Latest Episode Shows How First Photos of the Moon were Recovered

    written by chooolss on 2014-07-24 in #lifestyle
    The Invisible Photograph's Latest Episode Shows How First Photos of the Moon were Recovered

    You've seen the iconic images of the first manned moon landing. Now, marvel at these recently-recovered, very first photographs of the lunar surface!

    1
  • March Workshops and Events at Lomography Chicago

    written by Lomography Chicago on 2015-02-24 in #world #news #events
    March Workshops and Events at Lomography Chicago

    It’s been a long and cold winter but we’re finally getting back into the swing of things here in Chicago. We’ve got a great month of events and workshops coming up, so dust off those cameras that have been sitting around all winter and let’s take some pictures together!

  • Shop News

    Horizon and DigitaLIZA Bundle

    Horizon and DigitaLIZA Bundle

    The Horizon and DigitaLIZA Bundle lets you mix and match your favorite Horizon Camera, Lomography 35mm film and DigitaLIZA 35mm

  • LC-A Goes To: Saint Petersburg, Russia

    written by chooolss on 2014-06-05 in #world #locations
    LC-A Goes To: Saint Petersburg, Russia

    As the iconic LC-A celebrates its 30th birthday this month, we think it's only timely that we look back to Lomography's roots and shine the spotlight on the camera's birthplace, Saint Petersburg. If you haven't been there yourself, or if you have and simply wanted to be reminded of the beauty of the place, we've compiled a few select lomographs taken using no less than the LC-A by our community members!

  • Snippets and Vignettes: Famous Scenes from TV Series 'Game of Thrones' Rendered in 8-Bit

    written by chooolss on 2014-08-26 in #lifestyle
    Snippets and Vignettes: Famous Scenes from TV Series 'Game of Thrones' Rendered in 8-Bit

    Have a look at these cool .gif animations of some of the most iconic scenes taken from the fantasy and drama television series, "Game of Thrones!" But before you read on, we'd like to warn you about spoilers and generally NSFW images.

  • Scott Brasher Chases Fashion in the Streets of New York with the Petzval Lens

    written by antoniocastello on 2015-03-09 in #people #lomoamigos
    Scott Brasher Chases Fashion in the Streets of New York with the Petzval Lens

    Scott Brasher is a fashion street photographer based in New York City. His work has been featured on many media outlets while working with brands like Cover Girl, MTV, Reebok, and Target, among many others. But before this, Scott started shooting in the streets of Williamsburg, Brooklyn, capturing its daily urban fashion. Last month, he took the Petzval Lens to the streets of New York to photograph scenes at the famous New York Fashion Week.

  • Shop News

    Feed your LC-A 120 the finest emulsions and save!

    Feed your LC-A 120 the finest emulsions and save!

    Shoot more with LC-A 120 without breaking your budget! The Phoblographer Editor’s Choice Award Winner now comes in a Bundle with 120 format film at 15% off!

  • Take a Look at the Five Stylish Years of the Diana Mini

    written by shhquiet on 2014-08-18 in #news
    Take a Look at the Five Stylish Years of the Diana Mini

    The Diana Mini is turning five years old this month! Through the years we have seen this sweet and petite 35mm camera transform from a classic analogue beauty to a blinged-out snapshooter and everything else in between. Remember the Love Letters edition? How about the Premier Cru? To refresh your memory here's a gallery of all the Diana Mini styles we've released in the past five years. Which among these limited edition Clones is your favorite?

    1
  • How to Browse Photos on the New Site

    written by Andreas Bischoff on 2015-02-03 in #world #news
    How to Browse Photos on the New Site

    BIG NEWS: We've done a proper overhaul of how you browse photos on the Lomography site. We're pretty proud of the result and we hope you like it too! Check out the breakdown of the new features.

    10
  • Pee Film Soak By Brigette Bloom

    written by chooolss on 2014-08-07 in #gear #tipster
    Pee Film Soak By Brigette Bloom

    Photographer Brigette Bloom's series "Float On" and her rather unusual film soak recipe has been making the rounds in the Internet recently. But just in case you haven't seen it yet, Brigette has given us the green light to republish her recipe right here in the magazine's Tipster section! As she has so rightly put it, "Let’s all support each other and spread the creative energy!" Check out Brigette's tipster right after the cut!

    5