Fact or Fiction: Digital is Cheaper than Film

27

When I tell people I still shoot film they often ask ‘Isn’t that expensive?’ They assume that digital is cheaper because there is no subsequent cost of buying and developing film. But what people forget is the depreciation in the cost of their digital photographic equipment and the sheer quality of film.

I bought several digital cameras in the early 2000s that are totally obsolete now – I have a better digital camera on my phone! They are totally useless now. I couldn’t even sell them on eBay.

The last digital camera I purchased was a Sony SLR – which I bought for £280 (US$450 / EUR336) in 2008 for a trip to Nepal. I took about 500 photos with it on that trip and have used it infrequently since. That’s 56p per photo. Compare that to the last film camera I bought for a trip to the USA last month. The camera was a Pentax ME Super with a 50mm prime. I also picked up a zoom lens for it. All for £30 (US$50 / EUR37).

Pentax ME Super

On the USA trip I shot three rolls of black-and-white film and two rolls of Kodak Ektacolor 100ISO. The film cost me about £30 (US$50/EUR37) and the developing £15 (US$25/EUR19). So that’s £75 (US$120/EUR92) for 252 photos including all kit, film, and development – 30p per photo. That’s almost half the cost of digital!

Pentax ME Super

What’s more, the quality of film is far superior to digital. A medium format film image can record an equivalent of approximately 50 megapixels.

How much does a 50 megapixel camera cost? Significantly more than a Diana F+, I bet!

Medium Format: Bronica ETRS and Holga

Clearly, most people would shoot more than 500 photos on their digital camera. But what digital camera bought today will still be considered good quality will still be working in 30 years time? My guess – very few.

Of course, I can see the benefits of digital. I will continue to take the occasional photo using my phone camera. But I don’t want to give up the excitement of shooting film. For me I still consider it giving great value for money. It provides wonderful results and I love being able to call myself a lomographer.

written by bsmart on 2012-05-31 in #lifestyle #cost #value #developing #expensive #compared #film #cheap #digital

27 Comments

  1. sirio174
    sirio174 ·

    I returned to analog photography after two years of digital. Digital images are flat, and lack of plasticity

  2. mikeydavies
    mikeydavies ·

    i like the idea of if i bought a nikon d40 for instance, easy enough go to jessops or currys and buy one and someone else bought one too, if we took a pic on full auto (im not a photographer, i'll probs just use it anyway, doesnt it just figure out the best results anyway?) and if they took a pic of the same thing, it will look exactly the same, of course there is editing, but these things take time, you'll never get bored of the unpredictability of film and that feeling of buying a camera that takes the craziest pics and you dont even know it! the future is analogue!

  3. coolsigg
    coolsigg ·

    a well written article! my D700 had depreciated by about 1000GBP from 2009 to 2012. my lomo cams? hardly any depreciation! :) LOMO on!

  4. superlighter
    superlighter ·

    DIGITAL=KAPITAL
    I liked this article so much! BEAUTIFUL PICTURES!

  5. bsmart
    bsmart ·

    Thanks all @superlighter @coolsigg @mikeydavies @sirio174

  6. hakimbo05
    hakimbo05 ·

    Awesome Article!!!!

  7. chib3h
    chib3h ·

    :) I've been thinking about how to explain this issue to my friends and family for some time now... Now I'll just let them read your article..

  8. antibiotyx
    antibiotyx ·

    film photography = priceless!

  9. ashton1961
    ashton1961 ·

    Nicely done article!

  10. bsmart
    bsmart ·

    A flurry of activity on this article over the last few hours. Wonder why! @chib3h @ashton1961

  11. chib3h
    chib3h ·

    @bsmart Its probably cause lomography tweeted it on their account... :D haha

  12. joaomiguelsantoscunha
    joaomiguelsantoscunha ·

    I really, honestly, don't agree with you. Digital is cheaper, when you really do buy a good digital camera you get the money back quite quick. You don't pay films or development, and these are the main issues here! I can take 500 photographs in one day with my digital, but not with analogue. it would be too expensive. It's true it won't last forever, but neither will a analogue camera. It always depends on the quality you buy, a better camera will last longer, supposedly! I have a digital camera for 7 years now and she still works amazingly well, because back then I made a big investment in this camera. I haven't bought memory cards since then. So I did make the investment once and that was it! Of course, analogue is more fun! the waiting and wishing, the cries of joy when you get amazing results. But don't say it's cheaper, because it isn't! It's a very nice hobby, but still an expensive one. I'm not saying too expensive, but certainly more expensive then digital.

  13. bernizt
    bernizt ·

    I'm sorry but I agree with I have to agree with joaomiguelsantoscunha's comment. Analog is more expensive than digital. The comparison of digital cost vs analog cost can only be done if you compare the same amount of pictures taken with both mediums. It's true that the cost of the equipment makes a big initial difference (although there are both really expensive and really cheap digital and film cameras) but on the long term, if you use both digital and analog cameras, digital would always win in terms of price.
    I'm also an analog lover and I certainly get a lot of satisfaction from film, but price is not one of the reasons.

  14. deepfried_goodness
    deepfried_goodness ·

    Both digital and film have their places. I use both regularly, though film is now only as a hobby while professionally it's just digital. The cost for both how much you're shooting, and what camera you're shooting with can vary widely. A $60 Lomography Fisheye and a few rolls of film is a fraction of the price of a good DSLR and a good 8mm fisheye lens. However, a good 10.1 megapixel point-and-shoot camera is a fraction of the price of a medium format Mamiya with a dedicated fisheye lens. And while the point-and-shoot will depreciate quite fast, you'll also probably get a few thousand pictures out your initial $100 investment before the electrics wear out. Whereas a few thousand pictures of medium format is the price of a small car or a down payment for a house.

    I also briefly mentioned electrics wearing out. My current favorite camera to shoot with is a medium format Minolta Autocord from the mid 60s. I'm pretty sure it will still be working when my Canon DSLR has long been sent to electronics heaven. So there is also that aspect of cost to factor in.

    Having said that, very few of us have gotten into this for the cost. It's for the love of photography and everything that entails.

  15. brandkow93
    brandkow93 ·

    I shoot nearly exclusively film and my dslr is saved for ebay photo graphs, though i have to disagree with you, digital is cheaper, my 40D cost me £300 and has a minimum shutter life of 100,000 images so 300/100,000=0.003p a photograph, also you say medum format is 50 megapixels, yes that is true but with a plastic diana lens in front of it its not gonna look like it at all, with a hasselblad? yes. Also a diana or holga will never produce superior image quality to a dslr but it will produce a much wider dynamic range, have nice colours and tones. Both Digital and Film have there place in photography, and i dont know why some lomographers just bash digital for no reason. Like i said i shoot nearly exclusively film but i can appriecate digital photography and photographs.

    Also i completely agree with you when you say will " what digital camera bought today will still be considered good quality will still be working in 30 years time? My guess – very few." my geuss is non, my 40D is already obsolete and its only 4 years old, we live in a time of consumerism where companies bring out new products all the time, making the old one untrendy and seem low tech, whereas my trusty kiev 4 will never be obsolete.

  16. brandkow93
    brandkow93 ·

    Also one more thing, "film is unpredictable" is an incorrect statement, film its self is very consistant and isnt unpredictable, expired film does get a little unpredictable but the images from an the same expired roll will all look similar, Its the plastic lenses on many lomo cameras that make it unpredictable.

  17. savi0325
    savi0325 ·

    I too have found myself coming back to 35mm. I've been using digital for years, but then i started to see that it wasn't as fun as 35mm used to be. You didn't really put that much work into setting up the shot or enhancing your 'EYE' becasue you knew you could snap endless pics and get instant gratification. As soon as i purchased my lomo's, my love for film was brought back to life. Now i look at places with a new appreciation for them and love carrying around my cameras for those great shots. Digital is def a great quality product, but i think it speaks alot about the love for analoge when you have sites like instagram that take your digital stills and 'edit' them to look like 35mm shots. Imitation is the greatest form of flattery!

  18. freelancer
    freelancer ·

    Film is cheaper then digital? I don´t think so. Like brandkow93 said, about 100,000 images for the most dslrs. I don´t know about p&s digitals, because they have electronic shutters. But, lets be honest, it´s much more cheaper then film.
    For economical and of course for your bread&butter- professional purpose, you definitely go digital! No doubt! Thats how the world is moving right now. Go with the flow.
    BUT for ART - you go analog. For expressing yourself, for giving your images a soul - you go analog. For creating something that almost lasts forever - you go analog.
    Something that is and will always be used in governmental archives: MICROFILMS. You just need a magnifying glass and whatever lightsource you have at hand to read it! Also in a thousands of years. When all the digital memories faded away centuries before.
    A contemporary german photographer, named Jim Rakete, once said: "Film freezes the time, digital accelerates it."

    A lot of people have forgotten about analog photography, like they´ve forgotten about record/vinyl, nowadays. For example my father. He grew up with both of it and lived with it for about 50 years. But today he cannot handle my old filmcameras anymore!!! But he´s a pro with digital stuff!! Sounds kind of weird. Don´t you think? But when I show him some analog pictures I´ve taken, he loves the look of them. But cannot say why he prefers them over the digital ones.
    And that´s the good thing about it: As soon as people have "tasted" it again! They absolutely instantly fall back in love with it!!!
    Consciously or unconsciously - most people prefer analog photos because the photos are analog just like them.
    We humans are analog. Humans are not ON/OFF, black and white or 1 and 0 binarycodecs - they are analog. Different shades of grey. Like a good analog b/w-image! Even analog noise (grain) sounds better than digital clipping (noise). We are analog humans stucked in a digital world.
    Film is most beautiful, warmer, charming and cosier. But it is absolutely not cheaper!!!
    It´s worth it! Like a good wine.
    I hope my words make any sense to you.
    greez

  19. ariannapaloma
    ariannapaloma ·

    beautiful pictures and nice idea for the article!

  20. bsmart
    bsmart ·

    Thanks for taking the time to comments guys. Looks like I've started a bit of a debate here. All interesting, relevant points raised.

  21. carinaryca
    carinaryca ·

    I love this article and the pictures =) .
    Digital photography is good for photo manipulation, and you can always delete photos you dont like, I wont lie, I love digital. I just don't agree that film is cheaper, on a long term you will spend alot more money on film, development and scan than you would on a single digital camera, you can always buy a memory card with more storage space. The diference is that film is still awsome and it's worth the money, even if it's not that cheap, but that's just my opinion.

  22. foodeanz
    foodeanz ·

    Enjoy the magical and the beautiful moment of film while u can....Nice article...=)

  23. foodeanz
    foodeanz ·

    I agree with @savi0325...i'm not talking about whose cheap and whose not...just enjoy film format while it still exist in this world and share it with your family, child, friends and change their perceptions on analog cameras.Nowadays, people started to forget about the existing of analog cameras (35mm/medium format/110 format) and of course Polaroid camera (instant camera). Kids nowadays don't even know how to use analog camera.

  24. sapphire-st
    sapphire-st ·

    I enjoy both digital (hi+lo fi) and analog (films+instants). If I need to compare both according to expenses, I'd say digital cost less, but not cheaper. All the same to analog, it cost more, but not too expensive as some may think :)

  25. polarhei
    polarhei ·

    well, there are lots of things to consider, if you have the skill, then film (negatives) is really good and doing more things than digital.

    If you take some shots sometimes,film is still applicable. I now have to consider about this, but film is not in volume, in quality.

  26. buckshot
    buckshot ·

    @bsmart: Good article- well done for provoking this argument! @freelancer: Love your comment "We humans are analogue!" Too right!

  27. schemerel
    schemerel ·

    I guess it's kind of like making your own clothes. It's probably cheaper when you buy a dress at H&M, but nothing compares to carefully choosing your fabric and buttons, and putting in the work yourself and then proudly wearing your own creation. It's got more soul, you actually feel connected with your product. I hear a lot of people saying that because of the economy you should make your own things, when in fact its more expensive to do so, but I think that people (unconsiously?) aren't looking for a cheaper solution, but for a more personal solution. Because of massproduction things lose their value, and people feel like numbers. Thats why we love to slow things down and reconnect with ourselves, our possesions and the world itself. - at least, thats how I think about it.

More Interesting Articles

  • At the Funfair with my Horizon Perfekt

    written by sirio174 on 2014-04-12 in #reviews
    At the Funfair with my Horizon Perfekt

    Every year my city Como hosts, for the Easter period, a great fun fair. This is a great occasion to test a camera, to make experiments with films, to have fun and to photograph people while also having fun! This year, I used my gem, the wonderful Horizon Perfekt (that I bought from the Lomography Online Shop) loaded with a timeless film, a Kodak Tri-X 400 developed, as usually for b/w, by myself. Read more after the jump!

  • The Magic Yet To Come: Part 5

    written by Lomography on 2014-09-06 in #news
    The Magic Yet To Come: Part 5

    Last week, I received the strangest thing through my letterbox. It was a postcard with this photograph on 1 side. The photo is of me sitting by the sea whilst I was on vacation last year. But I have literally no idea who took this shot – That’s why I came here, to ask for your help on my search for my mysterious photographer and to try and get to bottom of the riddle they wrote me. Please help me if you can!

    10
  • A Salute to the Masters: The Democratic Eye (A Tribute to William Eggleston)

    written by sirio174 on 2014-04-19 in #lifestyle
    A Salute to the Masters: The Democratic Eye (A Tribute to William Eggleston)

    William Eggleston is one of the most important contemporary master and pioneer of color photography. In this article I write a tribute to his particular democratic way of looking around. For him "Nothing was more important or less important", and everything is worthy of being photographed. Again, he is fond of the dear old film; he said that "I don't think much about the digital world, because I am in the analog world!". Read more after the jump!

  • Shop News

    Petzval Buddies

    Petzval Buddies

    Petzval lens are designed for a Canon or Nikon SLR mounts and a selection of brass or black for each camera brand is available in our stores. And start shooting with images full of sharpness, crispness and bokeh effects!

  • Finding Humanity in the Streets with Soomin Yim

    written by chooolss on 2014-11-12 in #lifestyle
    Finding Humanity in the Streets with Soomin Yim

    Stop bath is a type of chemical used in the darkroom for processing black and white film, aptly named as such because it halts the development of the images. In this case, stop bath is also part of the title that Korean analogue street photographer <b><a href="http://instagram.com/sooeatsyourstreetforbreakfast">Soomin Yim</a></b> has given her body of work, "Stop Bath the City," to represent the forgotten faces of people in the city amid rapid modernization, captured and immortalized on black and white film.

  • Photo of the Day by alexlin

    written by Eunice Abique on 2015-03-31 in #world #news
    Photo of the Day by alexlin

    Spot the cat curled up tightly into a cute ball of fur.

    3
  • Total Eclipse of the Sun Competition Winners!

    written by bgaluppo on 2015-03-31 in #gear #news #competitions
    Total Eclipse of the Sun Competition Winners!

    In celebration of the mindblowing solar eclipse we had the other day, we ran a competition and asked you to tag your analogue photos centered around our great big yellow friend! Check out the winners now!

    2
  • Shop News

    Standard Photo Development Services

    Standard Photo Development Services

    Done shooting and want your films to be processed? We can process your colour and black & white 35mm, 120 or 110 films! Development, prints and scans are also included. (Service availability depends on your markets)

  • Awesome Albums: LC-A+ x Redscale XR x Countryside by Bnjmn

    written by Kwyn Kenaz Aquino on 2015-03-31 in #world #lifestyle
    Awesome Albums: LC-A+ x Redscale XR x Countryside by Bnjmn

    These redscale pictures make us imagine a darkroom out in the sunshine.

    2
  • James Wright's So It Goes x Sri Lanka Photo Diary (Part I)

    written by Julien Matabuena on 2015-03-31 in #world #locations
    James Wright's So It Goes x Sri Lanka Photo Diary (Part I)

    In December last year James Wright, editor and creative director of So It Goes Magazine, went on a two-week trip to Sri Lanka, "a place so long on our bucket list, but up until then, as yet unvisited," he writes on the first of his three-part photo diary. Herein is the first of his series that chronicles his adventures, highlighted by a selection of breathtaking images of the Sri Lankan countryside and the locals, among many other images, captured with his trusty photographic companions: the Leica MP, Lomo LC-A+, and an assortment of films including the LomoChrome Purple.

    2
  • Analog Sounds with Simeon Smith

    written by hannah_brown on 2015-03-31 in #people #lifestyle
    Analog Sounds with Simeon Smith

    Simeon Smith is a musician who recorded the sounds of our film cameras in action and made these samples available as a free download. We couldn't resist interviewing him about this project and taking a look at some of his photos. Meet the man behind the cams here.

  • Shop News

    Uncrate Long Lost Lomography Treasures - 30% Off in our Discount Section

    Uncrate Long Lost Lomography Treasures - 30% Off in our Discount Section

    Fly over to our 30% Discount Section to discover previously unavailable Editions & Clones! Be quick and make one yours before they are all gone again!

  • Россия в картинках (Russia in Pictures): Siberian Delight

    written by Julien Matabuena on 2015-03-31 in #world #locations
    Россия в картинках (Russia in Pictures): Siberian Delight

    In his latest travel series, Herr Willie shares a selection of fine photographs from his Russian adventures and tells the stories behind them.

    1
  • Kmonk is our LomoHome of the Day!

    written by Eunice Abique on 2015-03-31 in #world #news
    Kmonk is our LomoHome of the Day!

    From everyone here in Lomography, congratulations to kmonk for winning Home of the Day!

  • Thomas Hoepker's Lifetime of Wanderlust

    written by Kwyn Kenaz Aquino on 2015-03-31 in #world #lifestyle
    Thomas Hoepker's Lifetime of Wanderlust

    For sixty years, Thomas Hoepker traveled the world on assignment. The pictures from his far-flung expeditions are now in one book aptly called "Wanderlust".