Wide Angle Showdown: Vivitar Ultra Wide and Slim VS Canon BF-10

4

In this article, two wide angle beauties go head-to-head to see how they might appeal to us as Lomographers and to see who is the top dog of the wide angle compacts. Flares, colors, and vignettes abound! All this and more, after the jump!

The first camera that comes to mind to many Lomographers when you say “wide angle” is the vivid Vivitar Ultra Wide and Slim. A camera so famous that there have been many copies over the years, and it is regarded by many Lomographers as one of their favorite cameras. The Vivitar is light, inconspicuous, simple to use, and fun to shoot with. Its plastic lens gives all of what we Lomographers love: flares, saturated colors, soft focus, and simple operation. Yes truly this is a camera that has earned its fame, BUT there is another that offers some similar charms, along with some advantages over the Vivitar!

This camera is the Canon BF-10, a fixed focus camera with a glass lens, auto winding, and a built in flash! And that flash is the biggest advantage over the Vivitar, as this frees you from having to load a higher speed film, or modifying your camera to leave the shutter open for longer. another advantage over the Vivitar is the automatic winding, this means you can quickly snap a shot and not worry about forgetting to advance your film, and its quieter as well, making only a slightly noticeable sound. But this camera has one more advantage! A Self timer feature, making self portraits and shots on a tripod with little to no shake easy! And unlike some compacts with features such as these, the Canon BF-10 thankfully uses AA batteries. So shooting with this camera is both enjoyable AND affordable!

But other than that the cameras are pretty similar because:

  1. They both have shutter speeds around 1/100th of a second
  2. They both vignette and produce a soft focus effect
  3. They are both light and easy to carry
  4. They both have wider-than-average lenses (The Vivitar’s being 22mm and the Canon’s Being 26mm)
  5. They are both reasonably quiet and are easy choices for inconspicuous street shooters.

So now it’s time to compare images and show how the lenses differ in terms of their respective qualities. Both cameras were shot on Kodak Ultramax 400 film.

These are the photos from the Vivitar:

Credits: detroitlomo

As you can see, these photos are defidently wider than your average camera, and if you look at straight lines you will see the distortion caused by a focal length as wide as the UW&S has.

And here are the photos from the Canon:

Credits: detroitlomo

Now because the Canon has a slightly less wide lens than the Vivitar, the distortion is not as evident as with the 22mm lens. Also the shots appear to be more punchy in some respects. This may have to do with the coating on the Canon’s lens.

Now for the verdict. In terms of color saturation I would say this is a win for the Vivitar, it just gives out a more colorful image. In terms of Contrast however the Canon is the winner, because of its almost cross-processed style contrast in some shots. The winner in terms of portability and in terms of carrying it around, is the vivitar, because it doesn’t need batteries it would be my choice for a travel camera, just be sure to use it during the day, or in well lit areas unless you pack a high speed film. But if i was going for shots indoors with 400 ISO or below, The canon would be the one for me.

So this leaves us at a crossroads…There doesn’t seem to be a clear winner here. So! I’ll let you decide! Thats right folks! YOU get to be the almighty decider! Leave a comment below on which you think is the wide angle champion!

written by detroitlomo on 2012-04-04 in #reviews #vivitar-ultra-wide-and-slim #canon-bf-10 #wide-angle-lens #kodak-ultramax #compact-35mm

4 Comments

  1. brandkow93
    brandkow93 ·

    Great article, for me the CAnon looks better, better colours, better contrast although like you said the vivitar doesnt need battery, and it will vignette more, stilll the canon tough

  2. detroitlomo
    detroitlomo ·

    @Brandkow93 Yeah, its defidently a opinion thing, both are great cameras in all respects though

  3. superlighter
    superlighter ·

    Today I won a Canon BF-10 on eBay for.....0,01 Euro cent! can't wait to test it!

  4. detroitlomo
    detroitlomo ·

    @Superlighter Once you get your photos from it, send me the album link! I'll be interested to see them

More Interesting Articles

  • Lomopedia: Vivitar Ultra Wide and Slim

    written by cheeo on 2014-06-25 in #reviews
    Lomopedia: Vivitar Ultra Wide and Slim

    Loved by many toy camera fans all over the world for its compact and sleek packaging, the Vivitar Ultra Wide and Slim also delivers beyond aesthetics. See how this camera fares in another installment of Lomopedia!

    3
  • Useful Guidelines on Shooting with Ultra Wide Lenses

    written by jillytanrad on 2014-04-19 in #gear #tipster
    Useful Guidelines on Shooting with Ultra Wide Lenses

    Wide-angle lens are further divided into sub-classifications: Wide, ultra-wide and ultra-ultra-wide. Based on current standards, wide lenses for 35mm cameras are those with focal lengths ranging from 24 to 35mm. Lenses are considered ultra-wide if they have focal lengths from 17 to 21 mm, and ultra-ultra-wide if from 12 to 16mm. The New Russar+ is a 20mm lens; hence it falls under the ultra-wide classification. If you have an ultra-wide lens or if you intend to get the Russar+, you might as well make the most out of your precious investment. Read on for a few guidelines on shooting with ultra-wide lenses.

    2
  • Lomopedia: Nikon AF600

    written by cheeo on 2014-11-26 in #reviews
    Lomopedia: Nikon AF600

    Also known as the Nikon Lite Touch, this compact camera offers crisp wide-angle and panoramic shots from the get-go. Get to know more about this camera in this installment of Lomopedia.

    1
  • Shop News

    Summer Inspired Camera at 20% off

    Summer Inspired Camera at 20% off

    The brazilian summer inspired camera is now at 20% off! You can now celebrate life in full color and treasure every culture in a snap! This summer is no exception; make sure you’re prepared to capture all the sporty action with the Fisheye No.2 Brazilian Summer Camera!

  • Wide Angle Photography Tips: Photographing Architecture with the Lomo LC-Wide

    written by sirio174 on 2014-06-06 in #gear #tipster
    Wide Angle Photography Tips: Photographing Architecture with the Lomo LC-Wide

    In celebration of the 30th anniversary of the fantastic Lomo LC-A, and while waiting for the new Russar+ lens, I'll dedicate this article to an awesome super wide-angle camera: my Lomo LC-Wide that I like to use in architecture photography. Here you can read some simple tips I used to take a series of photos in the modern city of Latina in the center of Italy.

    2
  • December 18th Advent Offer: Save 10% On Film Today! (Online Code: FILMFANTASY10)

    written by jacobs on 2014-12-18 in #news
    December 18th Advent Offer: Save 10% On Film Today! (Online Code: FILMFANTASY10)

    With the holidays just around the corner, it's a great time to make sure you have loads of wonderful films for all the fun festivities coming up. Today's Advent deal of the day is here to help you do just that! Head on over to the Online Shop and save 10% on our wide selection of films. Do the right thing and keep your camera happy this year!

  • Score These Awesome Analog Treasures at Up to 50% Off!

    written by Julien Matabuena on 2015-04-18 in #gear #news
    Score These Awesome Analog Treasures at Up to 50% Off!

    Set sail to the Lomography Online Shop today and get limited edition items and other collectibles for less!

  • Shop News

    Wear lomo-love on your skin

    Wear lomo-love on your skin

    You’ve shouted your analogue love from the rooftops and worn your heart on your sleeve – Now it’s time to take it to the next level and wear it on your skin! Our new Lomography Tattoos are fun, easy to apply and come in five designs.

  • Derek Woods' 365 Days of Lomography Recap - February 14-28

    written by Julien Matabuena on 2015-04-18 in #people #news
    Derek Woods' 365 Days of Lomography Recap - February 14-28

    This latest update on Derek Woods' 365 Days of Lomography project covers the latter half of February and wraps up his two-month adventure with the LC-A. Dive in!

  • Meet our LomoGuru: ihave2pillows

    written by Eunice Abique on 2015-04-18 in #people #lifestyle
    Meet our LomoGuru: ihave2pillows

    Ed Choi regards Lomography as one of the best things that happened to him. In this interview, the latest member to join the roster of LomoGurus talks about how cross processing slide films sparked a great friendship, taking instant photos in Himalayas, and creating the perfect double exposure photograph.

  • Star Wars Mania 2015: The All-New Trailer

    written by Kwyn Kenaz Aquino on 2015-04-17 in #world #lifestyle
    Star Wars Mania 2015: The All-New Trailer

    The second trailer for "Star Wars:Episode VII - The Force Awakens" has the internet abuzz in the last last few hours. To join in on the fun, we scoured our archives and the cyberspace for some Star Wars treasures. Think Princess Leia and her double in that glorious gold costume, plus a photo of the new cast in roundtable discussion.

    1
  • Shop News

    Recognizable Images of Petzval

    Recognizable Images of Petzval

    You want your subject be the center of attention? Petzval lens are recognizable for sharpness and crispness in the centre, strong color saturation, wonderful swirly bokeh effect, artful vignettes and narrow depth of field that will make your subjects stand out!

  • Groovy Vintage Styles Photographed by The Séeberger Brothers

    written by Kwyn Kenaz Aquino on 2015-04-17 in #world #lifestyle
    Groovy Vintage Styles Photographed by The Séeberger Brothers

    Before Bill Cunningham and Scott Schuman, street fashion photography had Jules, Louis and Henri Séeberger.

  • Film Photography Day UK Party Recap!

    written by gise11e on 2015-04-17 in #people #events
    Film Photography Day UK Party Recap!

    It was great to see you all at the Film Photography Day party here at Lomography Soho! We had good fun and gave away some amazing prizes. Here is a recap of what went on.

    1
  • Why Film Still Matters in Calgary

    written by Kwyn Kenaz Aquino on 2015-04-17 in #world #lifestyle
    Why Film Still Matters in Calgary

    Jesse Yardley went around Calgary, Canada to find out what the slow art of film photography has to offer this mad-paced world. What he found out will have analog enthusiasts nodding.